patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

SPEAK OUT: Is Eldersburg Dangerous?

Two violent acts, a stabbing and a shooting, have people talking about safety in Eldersburg.

 

 

Two violent acts in less than a month in Eldersburg, a place that has been  ranked nationally as one of America’s best small towns, have residents sounding off about the safety of their community, which saw a fatal grocery store stabbing in June and a double shooting Friday that police said left one man dead.

“Jeez, bad month for murders in [the] Sykesville/Eldersburg area,” posted Annette Romanowski-Grigore on the Eldersburg Patch Facebook page in response to the Friday shooting.

Do you think the recent violence that made headlines in Eldersburg is a sign of increased crime—or are these simply isolated incidents? Tell us in comments.

“Fortunately, the fear of crime is far more prevalent than the crime itself—that’s consistent through the country and here in Carroll County and definitely in Eldersburg,” said Major Phil Kasten, spokesman for the Carroll County Sheriff's Office.

“It’s important in both of these incidents, as tragic as both of them are, in both cases, there was a swift follow-up,  [and] swift arrest through a joint effort between the law enforcement agencies and state’s attorney’s office investigation," Kasten said.

In the grocery store stabbing, Maryland State Police said Bergari Zardiashuili, 22, of Brooklyn, NY, was stabbed to death June 19 by co-worker Zamani A. Lawson, 26, of Jamaica, NY, after the two began arguing while on a cleaning shift at Martin’s supermarket.

And in the most recent incident, Maryland State Police said Jacob Bircher, 24, of Westminster, allegedly shot into a group of people standing outside the Harvest Inn just after midnight on Friday, July 13.

David J. Garrett, 36, of Sykesville, was pronounced dead at the scene. Gary Hale, of Woodstock, was transported to the University of Maryland Shock Trauma Center in Baltimore for the treatment of a gunshot wound, police said.

Police charged Bircher with first-degree murder, second-degree murder, attempted first-degree murder, and attempted second-degree murder.

A preliminary hearing in Bircher‘s case is scheduled for Aug. 10, according to online court records.

Maryland State Police investigators are looking into whether the victim and suspect in the shooting knew each other, said Lt. Scott Lowman at the Maryland State Police barrack in Westminster.

“It appears something provoked this guy,” Lowman told Patch on Tuesday.

Lowman also said witnesses told police “they’ve never seen the person before, but it doesn’t mean the victim did not.”

Overall, he said of Eldersburg, “While there’s been a spike in violent crime there, it’s not indicative of a trend. These two cases are isolated. When you have a homicide in Carroll County, it’s big news–whereas in a big metropolitan area, you have several a year.”

Both Lowman and Kasten said the two homicides in the last month in Eldersburg were the only ones the town has seen this year, and there were none in 2011.

According to Maryland’s Uniform Crime Report,  there were 4 homicides in Carroll County in 2010; 2 in 2009; and 1 each previous year until 2006.

Some Patch readers echoed the view of law enforcement—that the two recent violent incidents are not indicative of a trend.

“The incident at Martin's had nothing to do with this area,” wrote Chris Angelini Elrod on the Eldersburg Patch Facebook page. “They were not from the area. … The Eldersburg/Sykesville area is still a low crime area. Go check the stats with the police department. If you really think it is bad, try living in Baltimore City, or P.G. County. You will change your tune real quick.”

Related links:

Sign up for the Eldersburg Patch newsletter here and follow us on Facebook and Twitter for instant news updates and community conversations.

Related Topics: Carroll County crime and Eldersburg Crime

Donna

4:46 pm on Tuesday, July 17, 2012

If these were crimes committed on random people I would be concerned. The Martin's homicide was between two employees & I have a feeling that they will discover the people involved in the Harvest Inn homicide had some sort of history. I think these crimes were personal not random.

Reply
Patch_comments_icon

Lisa Rossi

8:16 pm on Tuesday, July 17, 2012

Thanks, Donna. That's similar to what I heard from police too. And the crime stats tell the same story--homicides are not a common occurrence in Eldersburg or Carroll County.

Reply

jag

9:19 pm on Tuesday, July 17, 2012

I agree with Donna, there is more to the Harvest Inn story then what we are hearing. What struck me odd with this story, where was Carroll County's primary law enforcement agency? The Sheriff Department? Not one word about them being involved in this incident.

Reply

David Bott

11:51 pm on Tuesday, July 17, 2012

I'm more worried about traffic related injury than violent crime in our town. Citizens know one another, neighbors watch out for each other, and we have great parent participation with kids. Those are more telling characteristics of a community like Eldersburg than the coincidental happening of two sensational crime events in one week!

Reply

Amy McGovern

9:23 am on Wednesday, July 18, 2012

I agree with David! The traffic is horrible! Accidents on Liberty Road at least once a week near Walmart. People do not drive safe around here. All the soccer Moms in their SUV's and Minivans (Killer cars) have their cell phones to their ears. Where are the cops?

Reply

Daniel

11:10 am on Wednesday, July 18, 2012

Sadly these events happen daily and occasionally will make their way to places like Eldersburg. The more the community grows, the more people fill the roads, stores, and homes. And thank you Amy.....I saw a bumper sticker "HANG UP AND DRIVE"! Where can I get one? Perhaps our Sykesville Police Department could distribute 2 stickers per family and every automobile in the community says the same thing! Talking and driving is a deadly combo. Everyone is in such a hurry? slow down...enjoy life and your families.

Reply

Brad Smith

3:03 pm on Wednesday, July 18, 2012

Our biggest traffic problem is due to Randallstown and Owings Mills coming out to shop in "the country" (not soccer Mom's as one would think), which used to be somewhat country before out of towners started coming to Eldersburg to shop. Curb this and you get rid of the traffic issue by a minimum of 50% and retarded driving by a minimum of 75%. The question is, how do you curb it?

Reply

Brad Smith

3:05 pm on Wednesday, July 18, 2012

You also cut down on crime when you limit the exposure to the higher crime rate areas such as Owings Mills and Randallstown.

Reply

jag

4:36 pm on Wednesday, July 18, 2012

I always thought the biggest traffic problem in Eldersburg was caused by parents who insist on driving their kids to and from school.

Reply

Brad Smith

4:42 pm on Wednesday, July 18, 2012

That is a common myth and it would mean that peak traffic would occur between 3pm and 4pm, and all of us know that isn't the case.

As for the morning, the biggest traffic issues there are the traffic coming into Eldersburg, I guess for work but I don't know.

Reply

JoeEldersburg

6:14 pm on Wednesday, July 18, 2012

I'd be interested if there is even a shred of scientific proof of your claims Brad, as I think they are a complete load of manure. While we may have the Big Lots and the Dollar General for awhile longer, until Black Oak rips down the mall, once the new Owings Mills Towne Center is complete, the folks you are complaining about will be lamenting your country butt coming to their town! :) Randallstown and Owings Mills are no more an impact on our traffic or safety as Westminster or Mt. Airy. Cell phones and electing dopes like Robin Frazier is what makes our roads so bad. We would have had the Boulevard District done long ago if she didn't turn away the 100% financing offer with a simple phone call in late 2001. Stop resisting diversity it's not the enemy...hate is!

Reply
Comment_arrow

Brad Smith

10:01 pm on Wednesday, July 18, 2012

Is there a shred of scientific proof to your claims that differ from mine? I know the crutch for liberals is to cry "where's the scientific proof" ... I'm not sure if that is what you are doing here, but either way that doesn't belong in this discussion. I don't need to be a SHA traffic engineer to make an observation, especially since I was here before traffic was such an issue.

They may be complaining about me (although I hate driving in Owings Mills, Randallstown is so so) and if the roles were reversed they'd have every right to. Pay attention to all of the traffic crossing the bridge in the morning from Baltimore to Carroll, anyone with general observation skills would be able to tell that there is a lot of traffic that comes from Baltimore to Carroll. Of course there is more traffic going from Carroll to Baltimore, but there is a surprising amount coming the other way. To deny that the culture and specifically the driving 'culture' (if you will) is different in Owings Mills, compared to Eldersburg is pretty absurd. Cell phone morons are everywhere, there is no doubt about that, so that's a wash as far as a comparison goes. Traffic safety can easily be changed but cutting down on sheer traffic volume.

I would actually love if they demolished Walmart and I had to drive 15 or 20 minutes to get to the nearest Walmart when I had to shop there.

Ross Dangel

6:26 pm on Wednesday, July 18, 2012

Hey Brad. I guess you don't work outside the county like I do or you'd know that all the traffic in the morning is leaving Eldersburg, not coming in and yes, going eastbound into Baltimore County (and south down 32) not inbound into the county. Where do you pull your stats from...don't tell, me I know. With respect to safety, our roads suck because the state now has no money to do the road improvements that were fully funded and approved back in like 2001 when Frazier turned down their offer.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Brad Smith

10:05 pm on Wednesday, July 18, 2012

Aside from telling you to sit at the liquor store and watch the smaller (than outbound Carroll traffic), but still decent volume of vehicles coming into Carroll via 26/Baltimore County in the morning, there's no point in me responding to you. I don't need 'stats', I have eyeballs. I could post a video for you, but then I don't feel the need to prove a fact that can be generally observed by anyone that wants to take a few minutes of their time and see for themselves. That just enables laziness, which isn't something I want to do.

Comment_arrow

JoeEldersburg

5:22 pm on Thursday, July 19, 2012

Brad, so let me get this straight, how does my request that you back up your xenophobic and bogus traffic statistics, relate to "liberals" and the need for scientific facts? Since when does any group or party have a monopoly on facts? You are either right or wrong and you sir, are very wrong indeed and your observations are likely driven by some personal bias that makes you see things differently than they actually are. "Driving culture"? That seems to have a very pejorative and racist overtone to me. And though I am no SHA engineer, I've certainly worked alongside them on Liberty Road's traffic issues and know your claims to be entirely false, so please pack your fear mongering away on the this score. I'm quite sure you can find another issue where it's less easy to have your "observations" challenged. Your orientation allows me to presume you are quite adept at finding tons of bogus facts to support your assertions.

Norma Bosley

8:49 pm on Wednesday, July 18, 2012

Hey, Brad, it's us good folks from Owings Mills that help the economy there by coming to shop. And OM's crime rate is not what you say. We have gotten a bad rap because of the mall but there's nothing much there to attract crime anymore. Thanx for picking on us, though!

Reply

Momwithteens

11:30 pm on Wednesday, July 18, 2012

Wait, I missed something...."outsiders" actually come to Eldersburg to shop? Why?! I agree with the previous poster, our community needs to do something about the cell phone talking/texting and driving issue! We need a massive hang up and drive campaign!

Reply
Patch_comments_icon

Lisa Rossi

12:20 pm on Thursday, July 19, 2012

Thanks for all the comments on this everyone. The next time I interview the cops, I will ask them about the texting/talking and driving issue.

Reply

JoeEldersburg

4:55 pm on Thursday, July 19, 2012

Lisa, please ask them to support a law, not on drivers, but for manufacturers to embed a chip that disables phones from texting while driving like they've had in Europe for years. This is the only way to ensure that we're not distracted and that less experienced drivers remain focused.

Reply

Brad Smith

5:46 pm on Thursday, July 19, 2012

It's no more valid then my request for you to back up your counter claims. No party has a monopoly on facts, it was an example that was lost on you to show scientific statistical data was not necessary in this discussion. All in all, neither requests are needed, just basic "scientific" observation. Do you travel 26 in the morning? If you did, you wouldn't be arguing against the point of the volume of traffic coming into Eldersburg.
"Racial overtones" is another crutch used by liberals, which doesn't belong in this discussion either, same with fear mongering http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fear_mongering , there is no need to bring red herrings into this discussion, you're better than that and I'll knock down any crutches anyway so why bother? I've encouraged everyone to make general observations with their own eyes, which is about as far from fear mongering as one could get. My observations are just that, observations but they are indeed accurate, don't take my word for it though ... watch the volume of cars entering Eldersburg in the morning on 26. It is of course smaller then the volume of cars exiting, but still quite high for a 'commuter town' as we are often referred to.

Cell phone impairment helps with driver awareness, but does not solve our traffic problem which is too much volume for our roads.

Reply
Comment_arrow

JoeEldersburg

6:35 pm on Thursday, July 19, 2012

Look back at your comments. You said that the cause of the traffic was coming from Baltimore...presumably shoppers or workers perhaps from Balt. County. Not true. Yes, I do commute on 26 and on 32 and I'm well acquainted with SHA models that indicate the usage of our roads. It's us. It's Carroll County and the shoddy roads that we have in Eldersburg, which were not adequately planned or invested in as we grew and were not designed to manage our traffic flow or safety. We have over 120 road cuts on a road meant to have less than a quarter that many. We had a solution in 2001, but Robin Frazier killed it. Now we will wait till hell freezes over for them to find over $50 million to build what was back then about a $30 million fully funded project. Do the research. Talk to the SHA office in Frederick. Don't guess. The bad traffic is most prevalent on the weekend and at rush hour and it's again us clogging our own roads, not your pretend invaders from Randallstown and Owings Mills.

Brad Smith

9:38 am on Friday, July 20, 2012

Well now we are getting down to where we actually differ in opinion. Although I agree that our roads cannot handle the traffic volume we have (obviously) I do not think the project Robin Frazier killed would have been an end all solution. The state keeps adding red lights and the road cannot get any wider, those are our biggest hurdles. The roads were very reasonable a few years before you moved here and still somewhat reasonable when you moved here. The census says the population of Eldersburg has grown an additional 2790 people from (about when you moved here) 2000 to 2010, but the traffic has grown exponentially more than that which points to outside traffic (simple deduction). It is not all from Baltimore County, but one obvious source of that is Randallstown and Owings Mills, I have many friends that will drive out to our Walmart from Owings Mills and Randallstown because it is "nicer" as they put it. As an example, there is a large amount of non Eldersburg residents that shop at our Walmart according to the census and this piles onto the traffic congestion, it isn't pretend invaders go there yourself and see. This goes back to my comments about shopping in the country.

Reply

JoeEldersburg

7:59 pm on Friday, July 20, 2012

No Brad. Actually it's the county that has approved the lights and cuts. Did it ever occur to you that the predominantly young families that moved here now have kids who are driving and as Carroll County is too stupid to include sustainable things like sidewalks and bike paths along our failed roads, we have no choice but to drive everywhere. Our retail footprint has grown significantly in the past 15 years, again because of zoning special exceptions (Walmart) and developer handouts. We've elected idiots like Frazier who don't understand long term planning or sustainability. They would rather gut our master plan than follow professional planning advice, because they think they know better. We suffer while the developers get their fees lowered. That's how it works now and prior to 2002 when Frazier was last Commissioner. We were the laughingstock then as we are again now.

Reply

Brad Smith

8:41 am on Saturday, July 21, 2012

Yes that did occur, but there were also kids graduating and going off to college or moving, etc. So that is most likely a wash, or close to it, albeit very hard to quantify. The children would have to be in the driving age and not go off to college to fit within the inclusion window, so I decided to omit that, but it could have a small small impact. Our retail footprint has more than tripled, again to cater to outsiders as our population has not grown to support all of that retail, I think this supports my previous comment. 26 is a state road, the county may request the lights be considered but the state maintains and controls that road. When they put up one of the idiotic lights I had to call SHA to complain because the county said it wasn't them. I don't care about being a laughingstock, I care about cutting down on traffic, so what's your suggestion, mine is to remove the retail. And what is the zoning exception Walmart got? Maybe they can be forced to close through that situation :)

Reply

Leave a comment