The pizza, subs, and salad are more than pretty good, but that's about where it stops. The service can* be so bad that we stopped going all together. First it was the dine-in experience. The waitresses are just soooo slow and forgetful. I am by no means a snobby patron, but when you bring apps at the same time as the main course (more than once) than we have a problem. Not only that, carry out and delivery have been wrong before, with no effort to make it right. So long J&P, it was fun while it lasted.
New York J & P Pizza
410-552-4400
Do you own or manage this location?
Claim it!
New York J & P Pizza was founded in 1979. The Eldersburg location is one of eight locations in Maryland, and is owned and operated by the Iliano Brothers. The menu offers a variety of Italian dishes including pizza and pasta, as well as subs, soups and salads. Fresh New York Style pizza is a popular menu item among the Eisenburg community. Monthly coupons are available online. New York J&P Pizza hosts fundraisers and sponsors local organizations.
- Hours: Sun - Thu, 10:30am - 10pm; Fri, Sat, 10:30am - 11pm
- Handicap Accessible: Handicap parking available
- Founding Date: 1979
- Payments accepted: American Express, Cash, Debit Card, Discover, MasterCard, Visa
- General services: Delivery, Eat-in
- Menu link: www.newyorkjandppizza.com/files/J_P_eldersburg_-_website.pdf
- Parking: Free lot
- Private events: Yes
- Cuisine: Bar Food, Italian, Pizza
- Features: Dinner, Group-friendly, Kids' Menu, Lunch, Private Parties
- Atmosphere: Bar Scene, Fun
At This Location
video profiles
Very good pizza. This is our go-to place for takeout pizza. It's not greasy and it tastes great! We've never had a problem with service.